Wednesday, 20 August 2025

Just Desserts?

According to the charity English Heritage, unless Somebody Does Something, the British Pudding will become extinct in the next 50 years. My immediate reactions were
1 - not in this family, mate - I know children who love puds!
2 - why are you worrying us about steamed puddings during these hot summer months?
The answer to #1 - here are their [dubious] statistics...

62% of British households stated they made puddings once a month or less [27%] or never [35%].
36% of people named steamed puddings [10%], fruit crumbles [19%] or pastry-based baked pies or tarts [7%] as their favourite puddings.
17% percent of 18-24 year olds named steamed puddings [4%], fruit crumbles [10%] or pastry-based baked pies or tarts [3%] as their favourite puddings. 45% of respondents over 55 named steamed puddings [11%], fruit crumbles [27%] or pastry-based baked pies or tarts [7%] as their favourite puddings.
838 people eat homemade traditional puddings at home, in comparison to 1405 people saying they ate ice cream at home. Ice cream is therefore eaten 68% more than homemade traditional puddings. Bad maths, and what happens to those of us who eat BOTH? or put i/c on their pies and crumbles?

The answer to #2 is - EH are about to launch "The English Heritage Baking Book" in a couple of weeks time. Cynical old me thinks they are 'scare-mongering' to get grannies to buy the book as gifts for their fruit&yogurt eating daughters-in-law.
Even though we do frequently have fruit and/or yogurt as dessert, I regularly serve up baked, home made puddings, like rice pudding [Rosie loves it] sponge puddings, fruit pies and cru
mbles. Luz made an excellent blackberry cobbler on Monday. Bob likes almost all puds [except lemon meringue pie] Any leftover cake is often turned into a hot pud, with the addition of fruit, custard etc. On Saturday I said "Well done, Jess, you have eaten all your first course" she replied "And is there  pudding, Grandma?" It was a hot day, so I'd prepared fresh fruits, sponge fingers and ice cream for a DIY Sundae. But often I give them something&custard.
EH name a few puddings which have already 'died the death' namely
Twelfth Night Cake - a fruity Tudor post Xmas pud. If your portion contained The Bean, you got to be Lord of Misrule for the day. It survived the Reformation, but was supplanted by our modern Christmas Cake [and the bean replaced by a silver 6d in the festive pud]
Cabinet Pudding a steamed sponge with glacΓ© fruits and custard. Also called Newcastle or Chancellor's Pudding. In the 1970s this was regularly on the menu at The Lamb in Norwich, I always chose I if Dad took me there for lunch. I must make it for Bob sometime*
Soul Cake  a spiced roundel of flour, butter, sugar, spices and currants. Dating back to 1511 or maybe earlier, these were given to poor people and children who went from house to house singing and reciting prayers at Hallowtide [the days surrounding All Saints/All Souls Days, Oct 31/ Nov 1st] A more wholesome Trick or Treat reward than a bag of Haribo...
Anglo Saxon cake honey, oats, butter and dried fruit, mixed and cooked over an open fire. Sounds like fruit flapjacks to me.
I checked out my older cookbooks and found lots of puddings I'd forgotten about. I think many modern women can't hang around the kitchen all day topping up the boiling water round the steamed Pudding. I do make puds, but avail myself of the modern technologies.
Microwaving sponge mixtures, happily leaving things unattended in the slocooker where they don't boil dry, using my pressure cooker, and air fryer...batch baking and freezing to eat later. 
I shall share some favourite pudding recipes in another post. 
Do you still eat puddings?

33 comments:

  1. We absolutely do eat puddings!
    Crumbles, tarts and pies, plus the French style clafoutis appear regularly in this house. They will not become extinct on my watch!!
    I confess I rarely make a steamed pudding but now have an overwhelming urge to do so, just to prove EH wrong!
    In fact….the last two days I have spent ages baking our harvest of St Catherine plums (very similar to a Victoria plum) with cinnamon to freeze them for plum and apple crumbles. I now have a small jar of cinnamon flavoured syrup after bagging up the plums and was wondering what to do with it……other than to pour it over ice cream! I was thinking now might be the time to actually try making ice cream with it! One of my first thoughts was "what would Angela do?"!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think I would pour the syrup over ice cream, waffles or pancakes. My daughter might add it to a cocktail.

      Delete
  2. Unfortunately not. Being diabetic has put paid to anything remotely pleasant to eat. Can’t even have a banana and custard, too high in sugar apparently. Eve’s pudding was one I made for small g.children but they are all grown now. The healthy eating police/diabetic nurses have a lot to answer for. Sandra.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Are you able to use Stevia or similar to sweeten things?

      Delete
  3. RannedomThoughts20 August 2025 at 08:57

    Sponge puddings are my default when I can't be bothered making pastry or crumble. I don't know how you can live with someone who dislikes lemon meringue pie, it would be a red line for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's fine, I just eat his portion! He has to live with a woman who doesn't eat cheese. In the Great Scheme Of Things, these are trivial issues.

      Delete
  4. I have a feeling stevia is now 'under suspicion' for side effects; I haven't gone in to it. Could just be from feeding tooooo much stevia to unfortunate mice which then get ill...
    I used to make puddings... Sussex Pond Pudding, a self saucing chocolate sponge (aka north sea oil slick, that dates it!) was another favourite, and a lemon pudding that miraculously sorted itself out into sponge and lemon curd sauce... mmmm oh yes, don't forget Steamed treacle sponge with thunder and lightening, a favourite when I was a child.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sussex Pond Pudding is a joy - but the very thought of it adds an inch to my waistline...

      Delete
    2. There is no sugar substitute that is without undesirable side effects. Stevia can cause digestive issues, lower your blood pressure (not good when your blood pressure is already low), and can lower your blood sugar (not good with diabetes as it interferes with your medications and too low is as bad as too high). Another problem is that it is frequently mixed with other sweeteners which cal also have side effects. The advice we were given was to avoid sugar substitutes as much as possible.

      Delete
  5. My husband loves puddings. Our youngest son is here for a few days and be loves puddings too especially with custard. We went blackberrying at the weekend and I made a blackberry and apple crumble which they both thoroughly enjoyed. I no longer eat puddings and mostly have fruit or yoghurt but I do love old fashioned rice pudding with nutmeg on the top but I have to omit the sugar from mine now. I think puddings will survive. Regards Sue H

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think puds will probably outlast the doomsayers at English Heritage

      Delete
  6. Sorry for the radio silence-I have been busy with my nursing duties! Puddings are only for very special times in this house as Norrie’s diabetes precludes having them. I still make a rice pudding but ration it carefully once made. Catriona

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As a post op convalescent patient πŸ‘️πŸ‘️ he deserves a treat!! I'm sure you are a great Florence Nightingale!

      Delete
  7. There is nothing quite like a proper rice pudding, with crunchy edges and a brown top! I rarely make pudding now, but have been stewing blackberry and apple from the garden. It will be an additiong to the freezer for a Winter day. Nothing beats a crumble!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a good time of year for the blackberry and apple harvest.

      Delete
  8. I love puddings, especially apple crumble and apple pie. In fact anything in a pie! I love rice pudding too, homemade with lots of nutmeg.
    I am diabetic but I can manage small portions and not every day. Carole R

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Small portions and not every day" is a good rule. The blessed St Delia says "I have puddings, but only at weekends"

      Delete
  9. We had lovely, filling puddings with our one shilling school dinners in the 60s, milk puddings, fruit pies, steamed puddings, crumbles, pancakes on Shrove Tuesday, Christmas pudding, stewed fruit and lots of custard.
    They were all freshly cooked from basic ingredients and sent out in insulated metal containers to the village schools.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Puddings were the best part of School Dinners in the 60s imho. I liked the steamed chocolate pudding with custard [cooked in huge cylindrical tin, and then they cut you a circular slice]

      Delete
  10. I'm not a pudding eater as it would be difficult in a household of one. Have you tried steaming puddings in a slow cooker? I use mine for primary cooking of my Christmas pud and also for reheating it. (I do not like microwaved Christmas pud.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, my slocooker is brilliant for steaming puds. m-waved xmas pud is a disaster, and you cannot reheat suet puds in a microwave, they become indigestibke cardboard

      Delete
  11. Puddings in all their myriad forms are still a great favourite with us although we should be watching the calories consumed a bit more than we do!
    Did you ever watch the TV series The Pudding Club? I have the recipe book that programme was based on ( or vice versa ) Lord Randall's Pudding is in the book - gorgeous
    So many puds , so little time πŸ˜‚
    Alison in Devon x

    ReplyDelete
  12. I don't remember The Pudding Club. I just looked up Lord Randalls Pudding. Apricots and Marmalade and steamed sponge sounds like a real winter warmer

    ReplyDelete
  13. A friend of ours claims he only likes 2 kinds of pie - hot & cold…

    ReplyDelete
  14. Twelfth night cake survives in France as Three Kings. I used to bake a bundt cake, like a crown, complete with bean, when my boy was small. I always marked the cake so his slice would have the bean. Then we'd bring out a gold paper crown for him to be king for the day.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I am not a pudding eater and Alan is, which could explain why he is diabetic and I'm not. I just don't have a sweet tooth, and hate the thought that the lovely savoury taste in my mouth after a nice meal would be smothered with the taste of something sweet. If he has a dessert while we are out I just have another black coffee.

    Funnily enough I have a little one portion shop-bought steamed pudding in my food cupboard, every time I see it there I think 'ooh I must eat that before the date is up on it'. One day I might!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have more of a sweet tooth than Bob. I love a pudding

      Delete
  16. DH's eyes light up when I bake a crumble or a cobbler! I find them less work than making a pie, and for me, the sweetness is usually complimented by plain Greek yogurt, especially on blueberry cobbler with a little lemon zest in the blueberries. DH prefers ice cream on his.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like yogurt on sweet puddings too. Home made yogurt is much cheaper than cream too

      Delete
  17. I have only eaten pudding once, lemon, made by my Nana in Hampshire when I came to the UK to meet my grandparents for the first time and stayed with them from Canada in 1976. It was delicious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. British puddings are fantastic. Visit us again and have done more

      Delete

Always glad to hear from you - thanks for stopping by!
I am blocking anonymous comments now, due to excessive spam!