I'm unable to verify the rumour that b-b-b appeared in a book about Freemasonry in 1924 [I suspect that's an urban myth]
The answer is the Unwritten Rule of Ablaut Reduplication.
And 99% of native English speakers have never heard of this- but most of them will follow this rule instinctively.
Let me give you some more common terms- ping pong, mish mash, flip flop, shilly shally, tick tock.
Let's try them the other way round pong ping, mash mish, flop flip, shally shilly, tock tick.
They just do not sound right do they? The URofAR says that "if there are three words with these vowels, then the order must go I,A,O - and if just two of them, then the I word goes first. Your horse's hooves all make the same noise when the hit the ground - but we still say clip clop, never clop clip.
Isn't it fascinating?
Maybe you think this is just a load of flimflam - if so, then go away and suck on a TacTic, until you understand what I'm on about!!
Note for word-nerds - ablaut simply means the variation of vowels in the same word root. From the German and Latin for 'off sound'
I'm off to practice my hip-hop in a sing-song voice! Hope I don't meet Boris Johnson playing ping-pong [or whiff-whaff as he calls it]
Soory Ang - I actually say Bish Bosh Bash (rather than Bish Bash Bosh) - possibly because the first time I heard it, the person said Bish-bosh-bash
ReplyDeleteHow intriguing. Now I want to know if the French have a similar rule - piff paff pouf?
DeleteSo interesting. I wonder is it the same in other languages? Ask Bob about French. (Not me!)
ReplyDeleteWhen I was a child we played, and sang out, "Ching Chang Walla". (Paper, rock, scissors).
ReplyDeleteThat is a fascinating rule! Ding dong is another one, of course. Musically, it feels like the i sound is stronger than the o and beat 1 is generally stronger than beat 2 in music. I liked learning the German word. Reminds me of my old favourite, the Umlaut!x
ReplyDeleteThanks for the musical input, Kezzie
DeleteThe interesting exception to this is Milly-Molly-Mandy!
ReplyDeleteYes, we thought of that too, but decided that Milly Mandy Molly just sounded all wrong. How about Mindy, Mandy, Monday?!
Delete